MLB Network credibility under question after not renewing Rosenthal deal

The perception that MLB Network by not renewing its deal with Ken Rosenthal “punished a well-liked and well-respected reporter for a fair critique of a widely despised authority figure" in MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred is “damaging to the network’s credibility,” according to Dan Gartland of League-owned media outlets are a “valuable resource” for fans. Silencing critical voices "calls into question the integrity" of the outlet. Fans "should be able to feel like the information they are consuming is different from North Korean state media." No one is expecting Rosenthal to be "allowed to bash Manfred" on MLB Network, but it is "refreshing when league-owned media outlets publish less-than-flattering stories.” MLB Net still has plenty of “talented, credible reporters” on its payroll, but it is “worse off” with Rosenthal gone (, 1/4).

: In Boston, Chad Finn writes perhaps the real sympathies should be directed at the hard-working reporters who remain at MLB Network, because the decision to dump Rosenthal did their reputations no favors." MLB execs, particularly original network President & CEO Tony Petitti, "have insisted since the beginning that they want MLB Network to be editorially credible and they would not interfere with the journalistic duties of the correspondents." Then, because the commissioner "cannot accept that criticism comes with his job," the network goes and dumps the “popular and respected Rosenthal for what were accurate rebukes." Though the perception is "not fair," Manfred’s actions "implicitly suggest that the reporters who remain are in lockstep with how the commissioner’s office wants the league covered." At the very least, they "now know what the consequences are for being critical of the boss." There is now a "cost for telling the whole truth." Challenge him "at your own risk" (BOSTON GLOBE, 1/5).

SBJ Morning Buzzcast: June 24, 2022

Excel Sports scores at NBA Draft; Breaking down year one of the USFL; DP World Tour finally states its LIV Golf policy and big names in sports invest in Jackpot.

SBJ Unpacks: Thaddeus Young, NBA forward and venture capitalist

SBJ's Austin Karp posted up with NBA power forward Thaddeus Young. The 15-year veteran discussed his venture capital strategy, his investment in technology and much more.

SBJ Spotlight: Predicting which U.S. cities will host World Cup matches

SBJ Facilities Writer Bret McCormick and Soccer Writer Alex Silverman say five U.S. cities are locks to host World Cup matches in 2026. But they have different ideas when it comes to the rest of the field.

Shareable URL copied to clipboard!

Sorry, something went wrong with the copy but here is the link for you.